Carleen Tanner's Positive Parenting
  • Home
  • Parenting
    • Parenting Notes (Blog)
    • Spring Semester Class List
    • Fall Semester Class List
    • Ask a Parenting Question
    • Babysitting Information
  • Marriage
    • Ask a Marriage Question
  • Traditions
    • Daily Traditions
    • Weekly Traditions
    • Monthly Traditions
    • Yearly Traditions >
      • Anniversaries
      • School
      • Birthdays
      • Holidays >
        • April Fool's Day
        • Christmas
        • Christmas Eve
        • Easter
        • Fourth of July
        • Halloween
        • Mother's Day
        • New Years Eve
        • St. Patrick's Day
        • Thanksgiving
        • Valentine's Day
      • Fall
      • Summer
      • Traveling/Vacation
      • Winter
    • Once-In-A-Lifetime
    • General Conference
  • Testimonials
  • Store
  • Speaking

Question/Answer

7/26/2019

2 Comments

 
Question
My husband and I are at such a loss. I have attended your classes, and we have tried to implement many of the things from the lessons. We are not perfect parents, but we do try to be consistent.

I am pretty much past the end of my rope with my 7 year old daughter. 
She lies constantly - about everything from big things to insignificant things. 
She is very disrespectful when we try to suggest a way to do something different, or help her, or discipline her - yelling, screaming, crying, saying that everyone hates her and she is horrible (she has even mentioned that she just 'shouldn't be on this earth anymore' a couple of times which terrifies us). 
Lastly, it seems like *every* chance she gets, she will break the rules of the house. If I'm on the phone, if I go take a shower, if we have put her to bed for the night. Any time she is not directly supervised she tries to be sneaky and break some sort of family rule.

I just feel like such a failure as her mother, and I truly do not know what to do. I have spent so many nights on my knees, and perhaps I am not patient enough or something - I just am at a loss. If you have any thoughts or suggestions - we would welcome them wholeheartedly. Thank you.

Answer
 I am so sorry that you are struggling with this little one.  It is so hard to give advise when I know so little about your family, her place in it, and her individual little personality.  I do know that she sounds like  a very discouraged little girl.  I also know that when children seem to be acting out on everything it is hard to show them love. Sometimes when children get on this downward cycle of misbehavior they do not have the emotional strength to change.  It is sort of like they have to act the way they feel you see them.  Right now, I think she feels that you see her as a "bad" person so that is how she is acting.  I do not know if there is another child in the family that is a "good" child but that could also discourage her more as she feels that she cannot compete with the good one. I think more than lots of discipline for her every act of misbehavior, she needs to feel loved.  This may seem counter intuitive, but she needs emotional courage before she can have the strength to change her behavior.  Focus on telling her 10 positives a day.  Plan a date with just her.  Stop focusing and praying for a way to change her negative behavior and pray to find a way to fill her little soul with your love!

I love the quote from President Packer:
True doctrine understood changes attitudes and behavior.  The study of the doctrines of the gospel will improve behavior quicker than the study of behavior will improve behavior.  Preoccupation with unworthy behavior can lead to unworthy behavior. "

I had a daughter that felt this way about one of her children once.  She sent that little boy to me for a week so I could give him the love she could not right at that time. I don't know if you have a grandma she could visit for a few days so you could both get a break from each other.......

If not then I would suggest that for the next  week you focus only on the positive in her life.  Pray that Heavenly Father will show you her spiritual gifts and share that insight with her.  Tell her she has an important role in this life and you have faith in her.  Ask Heavenly Father to help you see her as He sees her.  Visualize her sitting on the Savior's lap and seek to hear the words He would be saying to her.  Spend this week just trying to fill her emotional bank account and helping her feel important. Try not to react to every little thing she does wrong....You still have plenty of time to correct bad behavior.  Focus this week on telling her what you would like her to do instead of what you do not want her to do.  Try it for a week.  Help her to feel loved!  How can she feel the Savior loves her if she feels you do not?

Also you seem pretty discouraged.  You need to see what you can do to fill your own personal emotional bank account.  Do something for yourself that makes you feel closer to the spirit.  You need that added strength and peace that comes with the spirit.

I am not saying just read your scriptures more or pray more...(though you might evaluate where you are on those things)...just find something that brings you great joy and do it!  Sometimes strong emotions prevent us from hearing the answer to our prayers as the spirit whispers very softly.  I know that Heavenly Father is answering your prayers for yourself and your little one.  The question is: is your soul still enough to be able to hear it?

Heavenly Father loves you so very much and He also loves your little girl.  You are certainly not a failure as a mother...just a discouraged mother with a discouraged little girl.

May Heaven bless you, I know that Heaven loves you!!!!
​
Carleen Tanner

 
2 Comments
Janese
7/26/2019 06:25:36 pm

Hello,
First, I just want to send you a hug and tell you that you are not a failure as a mother. It’s a feeling I know all too well. And it’s something I have to remind myself of still. I have been through similar struggles with my son. When he was about 7 we reached the end of our rope and started a parent/child behavior therapy with him. This did help improve our relationship, but the last three years have been a long and hard road. In that time my son has been diagnosed with ADHD, anxiety and depression. We have used a functional Dr to balance out his levels of copper (5x times normal which was a huge part of his depression), and other minerals that are out of balance in his little body that affect behavior and mood. Sometimes the behaviors can’t be completely cured by love. There are chemical imbalances in the brain. My son isn’t a bad kid, but his impulsivity gets him into trouble. It makes him reactive and aggressive at time. A lot of what you’re describing sounds a lot like things that kids with ADHD struggle with. (Lying, anger, temper tantrums, low self esteem) My advice is pray to be led in the right ways to help your daughter. It wasn’t until we sought outside help that we began to see changes. It’s been a long three years of therapy, dr visits, even a private school (which I never would have thought of as an answer but Heavenly Father provided a way). Heavenly Father knows your daughter best, He knows what she needs, and He entrusted her to you because he knows you can do this. Our answers have come, through people and therapists a school and even Medicaid to pay for it all. Trust that you can be led too. We are far from the end of our struggles with our son, but after 3 years of therapy, some lifestyle changes, supplements and now even medication, he is doing so much better! I’m happy to talk with you more if you like about paths that have opened up for us on our journey. Or if you just need a shoulder to cry on. I’ve been through similar experiences. It is scary to have your child talk about ending their life (mine still does sometimes) and hear how much they dislike themselves. It still breaks my heart, but it’s nothing you have done! Know that. You will find your own answers. And yes, keep loving her!

Reply
Angie
9/17/2019 09:25:48 am

I have a little boy, interestingly the same age, who struggles the exact same way! This is a very encouraging post and I'm thankful for your helpful words Carleen! I have felt some inspiration already in this direction - to focus on the positive and just fill that kid with love. Also, FUN! I am learning that he needs a lot of positive words, affection, attention, and fun! He still does a lot of mischievous things, but I've started to realize that some of them just don't matter. (Sneaking the jar of Nutella and eating it with a spoon in the bathroom?? Sigh. Not worth breaking his spirit over. Maybe next time I should join him?!)
Thanks again for the supportive words.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Carleen Tanner

    Notes from classes and other information will be posted here.  Also you can order syllabus and CDs from the store or check out the "Traditions" that class members have shared.  You can also ask a Parenting and/or Marriage Question.

    Archives

    September 2019
    July 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013

    Andrea Hansen

    I will be posting my class notes from Thursday Parenting Class within a few days after class.

    Categories

    All
    Adversity
    Agency
    Apologies
    Atonement
    Attitude
    Babies
    Blended Families
    Bolton Institute
    Budget
    Cd
    Cell Phones
    Church Attendance
    Coach
    Color
    Color Code
    Communication
    Competition
    Consequences
    Contention
    Cooperation
    Dating
    Depression
    Differences
    Discipline
    Discouragement
    Doctrine
    Encouragement
    Entitlement
    Family
    Family Home Evening
    Fathers
    FHE
    Filter
    For Strength Of Youth
    General Conference
    Goal
    Gratitude
    Holiday
    Holy Ghost
    Holy Ghost
    Humility
    Information
    Internet
    Love
    Love Language
    Marriage
    Media
    Money
    Morality
    Mothers
    Order
    Organization
    Parenting
    Personal Revelation
    Plan Of Salvation
    Ponder Pad
    Pornography
    Power Struggles
    Praise
    Prayer
    Prayers
    Pride
    Reading
    Referee
    Reminders
    Reverence
    Sabbath Day
    Scouts
    Scriptures
    Scripture Study
    Self Esteem
    Service
    Spirit
    Stress
    Summer
    Survey
    Teaching
    Technology
    Temple
    Thanksgiving
    Thoughts
    Traditions
    Trials
    Valiant
    Values
    Violence
    Website Links
    Women
    Work
    Young Women
    YouTube

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.